No jumping to conclusions about the role of exercise in brain health

Despite the intriguing findings, this study does face some specific limitations.

First, some of the data came from participants’ self-reports, which means it can be inaccurate. Then, almost 65% of participants were white, and about 35% were women, indicating the need for greater diversity in future research and a limited ability to generalize the results.

The findings also cannot be generalized to groups with certain conditions not represented in the SPRINT study, such as those with diabetes. The exclusion criteria of the current analysis could also have impacted the results.

The authors further acknowledge that their study “likely lacked the adequate statistical power to detect the benefit of [vigorous physical actvity] on the risk of probable dementia.”

There is also a potential confounding risk, and researchers only looked at baseline data for vigorous physical activity. Changes in vigorous physical activity could have impacted cognitive outcomes.

Moreover, the researchers did not look at how moderate physical activity or the potential negatives of sedentary behavior could affect cognitive status. Finally, mild cognitive impairment “at the time of enrolment was not adjudicated,” which could have impacted the results.

Future research can allow for longer follow-up times to confirm the findings of this research. Kazibwe noted that future research could include “[s]tudies using device-assessed physical activity in large and diverse populations are needed to investigate the benefits of vigorous physical activity for protecting against cognitive decline.”